NSS status and novelty checks

Checked 2026-11-20. This is a search record, not a guarantee that no unpublished or unindexed proof exists.

Exact primary statement

Contemporary status

  • Yair Lavi, specialist Conjecture 27 page: https://yair-lavi.com/mincs-list/conjecture-27/index.html . Historical status (November 15, 2026): listed Open. Finite row-sum-four counts were explicitly distinguished from a disproof of an unspecified O(p) bound.
  • Status update (November 20, 2026): Lavi's Conjecture 27 page now lists Disproved by others, credits Cinna Davis and GPT-6.2 Astra, and says an independent audit found no gap in the argument. The public page records both the qualitative disproof and quadratic lower bound. This is external confirmation, not a refereed publication.
  • Repository open coordination issues examined before proposing lane. Existing claims concerned other named conjectures; no NSS claim found.

Query families checked

  • Nemeth Seberry Shu conjecture permanent solved / disproved / counterexample
  • distinct permanents prime circulants superlinear
  • circulant permanent O(p) conjecture
  • distinct permanents McCullagh
  • Nemeth Seberry Shu 2026
  • exact original title and author names

Search results located original paper, surveys, Lavi status, sparse-degree experiments and unrelated permanent work, but no full resolution. Another independent agent separately verified scope and searched for resolution; see independent-audit-erdos.md.

Dependency versus proposed contribution

The uniform determinant estimate is not new. It is used from Divoux–Wang arXiv:2610.23755v1, Proposition 3.1, with their attribution to McCullagh2014. New candidate contribution: binary sinusoidal Fourier profiles with cardinality correction, determinant-factor separation uniformly over a linear number of degrees, and use of the prime congruence to obtain V(p)/p→∞. The cardinality/Fourier lemma, concentration inequality, Parseval identity and modular permanent observation are elementary ingredients, not separately asserted novel.

The disproof gives superlinear growth, and the quantitative refinement gives a quadratic lower bound. Neither settles the fixed sparse row-sum conjecture.