Chen–Khare–Sahi's conjecture

What Lean checks

Lean proves the exact source Conjecture 5 counterexample, the whole rectangular-translate family, and the continuous small-positive-q family for every 3/4≤t<1. It verifies the full real semiring, mixed-degree reduction and saturation, and unique monic triangular eigenfunction characterizations including shifted supports. Strict compilation and isolated kernel replay passed; the full repository gate remains pending.

The Muirhead-semiring implication in Conjecture 5 of Chen, Khare and Sahi's Majorization via positivity of Jack and Macdonald polynomial differences is false. The normalized Macdonald difference for (4,2,0)≽(4,1,1)(4,2,0)\succeq(4,1,1) at q=1/10,t=9/10q=1/10,t=9/10 lies outside the full Muirhead semiring.

A rational linear functional is nonnegative on every product needed to generate the degree-six part of that semiring, while its value on the Macdonald difference is

−4538292661539106631184392870<0.-\frac{4538292661539}{106631184392870}\lt0.

The proof covers all semiring products through an exhaustive reduction to 38 products and seven ordinary monomials. It also proves that every rectangular translate of the partition pair is a counterexample. A Hall–Littlewood calculation supplies a continuous family of parameters with the same obstruction.

This disproves the full equivalence asserted in Conjecture 5 through its semiring clause. The weaker evaluation-positivity inequality remains a separate question; Sra has proved that inequality for this same partition pair. The Jack-semiring Conjecture 4 is not resolved by this package.

Files

All three verification scripts use only the Python standard library:

python verify.py
python independent_cone_check.py
python independent_orthogonality_check.py

The written argument and rational certificates are complete. They have been independently reviewed within this research campaign; no external peer-review claim is made. Lean formalizes the exact source counterexample, the rectangular-translate family, and the continuous-parameter refinement, including the full real semiring and monic triangular eigenfunction characterizations. The repository-wide verification gate remains pending; see the Lean status report.

Primary source: Hong Chen, Apoorva Khare and Siddhartha Sahi, arXiv:2509.19649v2, Conjecture 5, equation (5.7). Coordination and discovery history are in issue #201.