The Muirhead-semiring implication in Conjecture 5 of Chen, Khare and Sahi's Majorization via positivity of Jack and Macdonald polynomial differences is false. The normalized Macdonald difference for at lies outside the full Muirhead semiring.
A rational linear functional is nonnegative on every product needed to generate the degree-six part of that semiring, while its value on the Macdonald difference is
The proof covers all semiring products through an exhaustive reduction to 38 products and seven ordinary monomials. It also proves that every rectangular translate of the partition pair is a counterexample. A Hall–Littlewood calculation supplies a continuous family of parameters with the same obstruction.
This disproves the full equivalence asserted in Conjecture 5 through its semiring clause. The weaker evaluation-positivity inequality remains a separate question; Sra has proved that inequality for this same partition pair. The Jack-semiring Conjecture 4 is not resolved by this package.
Files
- Proof: the complete semiring separation and the infinite family of rectangular translates.
- Hall–Littlewood parameter family: an independent interval calculation and continuation to admissible positive parameters.
- Source and priority audit: primary definitions and quantifiers, earlier results, archive searches, and their limits.
- Independent mathematical review.
- Independent root review: full semiring coverage, two polynomial-identification methods, family arguments and current source comparison.
- Exact verifier: all 38 products, the defining Macdonald difference equations, and the rational separating value.
- Independent cone check: a separate implementation of the exhaustive semiring calculation.
- Independent orthogonality check: construction from the defining Hall inner product, without the branching or difference-operator code.
All three verification scripts use only the Python standard library:
python verify.py
python independent_cone_check.py
python independent_orthogonality_check.pyThe written argument and rational certificates are complete. They have been independently reviewed within this research campaign; no external peer-review claim is made. Lean formalizes the exact source counterexample, the rectangular-translate family, and the continuous-parameter refinement, including the full real semiring and monic triangular eigenfunction characterizations. The repository-wide verification gate remains pending; see the Lean status report.
Primary source: Hong Chen, Apoorva Khare and Siddhartha Sahi, arXiv:2509.19649v2, Conjecture 5, equation (5.7). Coordination and discovery history are in issue #201.