Status: complete analytic disproof. Separate internal reviews by the root and algebra agents found no mathematical gap. See issue 100 and NOVELTY.md for the bounded prior-resolution audit. The proof gives intervals of counterexamples and does not infer a theorem from a finite numerical calculation.
1. Source and precise assertion
Ferreira and Simon define
The reciprocal gamma function is interpreted by its entire extension, including its zeros at the nonpositive integers. For and , their random variable has density
For , their Theorem D defines as the unique root in of
Their proof in §5.1 shows that the left side is positive for and negative for . They set , and also set for .
The unnumbered conjecture in §6.4 asserts, for all admissible parameters,
Here .
Source: R. A. C. Ferreira and T. Simon, On the log-concavity of the Wright function, Constructive Approximation 60 (2024), 309–338, DOI. The accessible primary arXiv v2 has Theorem D on printed page 5, its relevant proof on pages 15–16, and the conjecture on pages 23–24.
2. Counterexample families
Theorem. Both of the following statements hold.
For every sufficiently small , the parameters
satisfy , but is not log concave.
For every sufficiently small , the parameters
satisfy , but is not log concave.
In both cases the log-concavity inequality fails at . Thus the first implication in (2) is false, including at interior parameters with .
3. A locally uniform limit
Fix and . For sufficiently small, put
We prove that, on every closed disk , and each of its fixed-order derivatives converge uniformly to those of
Write . For , the classical reflection formula (DLMF 5.5.3) gives
This formula also holds when is an integer, by continuity of . Choose . Since ,
Gamma is positive and log convex on the positive half-line; see the Bohr–Mollerup characterization. Its values at the endpoints of are and . Hence
Using in (7), we obtain the bound
For each fixed , the right side of (7) tends to as . At , the coefficient equals
which tends to and stays bounded near . It is identically zero if .
For any fixed derivative order , the differentiated terms with are dominated on by
The sum of these bounds is finite for every . Dominated convergence for the power series proves the assertion, in particular convergence of the first two derivatives. No expansion uniform in is assumed; inequality (8) supplies the required uniform domination.
4. The curvature calculation
For a positive twice differentiable function , log concavity requires
because . By the limit just proved,
locally uniformly for . Direct differentiation of (6) gives
In particular,
For the boundary family (3), take . Then
so . It follows that for all sufficiently small positive . The source's extension makes the threshold condition automatic.
For the interior family (4), take . Then
and
Consequently,
The first expression is exactly
For sufficiently small , we have , , and (12) is strictly positive. By the source's unique-threshold characterization, . The second limit in (11) gives the failure of log concavity at .
Finally, multiplies by the positive number . Both sign conclusions therefore hold for the normalized probability density. This proves the theorem.
5. Scope
More generally, every fixed satisfying gives the same counterexample family for all sufficiently small . If , this condition is ; if , it always holds. Equations (8)–(12) prove this statement without further estimates.
The proof disproves the complete conjectured equivalence by disproving its threshold-to-density implication. It makes no claim about the remaining equivalence between density log concavity and reciprocal Mittag–Leffler convexity at parameters outside the theorem. Every counterexample has ; the degenerate limit is used only to prove the limiting formula. No explicit numerical value of a small parameter is needed: the strict limiting signs prove an interval of admissible counterexamples.