Kovalev's conjecture

What Lean checks

Complete proposed analytic disproof of the lower Hardy-duality comparison by a uniform positive diagonal matrix family in every order at least 500001. Independent mathematical and root reviews passed, with two exact arithmetic replays and a separate priority audit. The upper inequality is not resolved. No Lean formalization is claimed.

This package gives a proposed complete disproof of Conjecture 6.1 in Leonid V. Kovalev's Hardy-type norms of matrices, arXiv:2607.17373v1, printed page 9. It constructs positive diagonal counterexamples to the conjecture's lower inequality in every matrix order at least 500001. The argument is uniform in the order; no list of finite-dimensional checks is used.

The conjecture proposes two inequalities between a spherical fourth-moment norm and the dual of the spherical first-moment norm. A supporting functional, with the source's normalized trace pairing, gives matrices whose dual norm is exactly one. For an input with one large singular value and many equal small singular values, conditional Jensen and the variance of a chi-square average reduce the disputed bound to two fixed one-dimensional Gaussian integrals. Classical modified-Bessel formulas and elementary rational estimates then give a strictly positive separation from the conjectured constant.

The lower inequality is false, which refutes the full conjunction. This package does not settle the remaining upper inequality or determine the smallest possible counterexample dimension. The threshold 500001 is chosen to keep the uniform proof simple.

Evidence

Reproduction

python3 verify.py
python3 review_constants.py

Both checkers use only Python's standard library and exact rational arithmetic. They verify the finite comparisons in the written analytic proof. The proof's positive separation above the rational upper bound for the conjectured threshold is

837096071974739350815872884920430400000000000000000000000000>0.\frac{8370960719747393508158728849} {20430400000000000000000000000000}>0.

The first independent mathematical review and the separate source/priority audit passed. The argument remains unrefereed; internal review is not journal peer review. No Lean formalization is claimed. The current audit found no earlier resolution within its documented coverage.