Karp–Vishnyakova–Zhang's gamma-quotient conjecture

What Lean checks

Written all-order sign-regularity proof with exact signature and integer rank cutoff; finite determinant checks are supplementary.

The all-order sign-regularity assertion is proved for every positive parameter difference. The proof also gives the exact signature and the integer-parameter rank cutoff. The source's proposed fixed order-three signature is corrected within the same theorem.

Result

Set δ=c−d>0\delta=c-d>0. For every ordered grid with positive denominator arguments, the kernel

K(x,y)=Γ(c+x+y)Γ(d+x+y)K(x,y)=\frac{\Gamma(c+x+y)}{\Gamma(d+x+y)}

is sign regular of every order. If δ\delta is not an integer, every order-rr determinant is nonzero with sign

εr(δ)=sgn[(−1)(r2)∏j=0r−1δj_].\varepsilon_r(\delta) =\mathop{\mathrm{sgn}}\left[ (-1)^{\binom r2}\prod_{j=0}^{r-1}\delta^{\underline j} \right].

Here the underlined exponent denotes a falling factorial and its order-zero value is one. For δ=m\delta=m a positive integer, the signs through order m+1m+1 are (−1)(r2)(-1)^{\binom r2}, and all larger minors vanish.

In particular, the third-order sign is positive when 0<δ<10<\delta<1, negative when δ>1\delta>1, and zero when δ=1\delta=1. The fixed signature (+,−,−)(+,-,-) suggested in the source is therefore incorrect on the first interval. This correction is not counted as a separate conjecture resolution.

Proof mechanism

The gamma-density kernel

G(a,u)=ua−1e−uΓ(a)G(a,u)=\frac{u^{a-1}e^{-u}}{\Gamma(a)}

is strictly totally positive. The power kernel (u+v)δ(u+v)^\delta has the stated sign sequence, as follows from an explicit Wronskian and Rolle's theorem. The exact identity

Γ(x+y+δ)Γ(x+y)=∫0∞∫0∞G(x,u)(u+v)δG(y,v)dudv\frac{\Gamma(x+y+\delta)}{\Gamma(x+y)} =\int_0^\infty\int_0^\infty G(x,u)(u+v)^\delta G(y,v)\,du\,dv

transfers those signs to the quotient through two continuous Cauchy–Binet formulas. The proof includes absolute-integrability and strictness arguments, so it applies to every order without a limiting numerical claim.

Files and verification

  • PROOF.md contains the complete proof, including the Wronskian criterion, translated domains, and integer rank.
  • NOVELTY.md records the exact source, related results, public-solution checks, and access limits.
  • verify.py is a standard-library exact rational diagnostic. Run python results/kvz-gamma-quotient/verify.py from the repository root.
  • Independent analysis audit and root audit record two separate internal reviews.

The verifier passes 115 exact rational checks. It verifies half-integer signs, integer rank cutoffs, and integer gamma-moment normalizations. As a small certificate for the order-three correction, at δ=1/2\delta=1/2 and xi=yi∈{1/2,3/2,5/2}x_i=y_i\in\{1/2,3/2,5/2\}, the determinant is 5π3/2/8192>05\pi^{3/2}/8192>0. Finite checks are supplementary to the general proof.

The target appears in Section 3, item 11 of Karp–Vishnyakova–Zhang, published in Results in Mathematics 80 (2025), 112, DOI 10.1007/s00025-025-02431-4. No earlier complete resolution was found in the inspected sources. Internal reviews are complete; outside peer review is not claimed.

Coordination: issue 97.