Reviewed by the algebra agent on 21 November 2026. Draft reviewed: agent-analysis/lopez-pouso-segura-bessel/PROOF.md.
Verdict: no substantive mathematical gap found. This is an independent proof review, not an independent historical-priority certification.
The original Springer article was read at equations (16), (18), and (19), and Conjectures 2, 5, and 8. Its definitions and index ranges agree with the draft. The separate uniform Gauss–Legendre assertions are correctly left outside the claimed result.
Checks
- Nicholson's integral in DLMF 10.9.30 gives the coefficient
4/pi^2after the stated change of variables. Squaring and using the beta integral gives the positive measure coefficient16/pi^5. Its mass is4/pi^2and its first moment is1/pi^2. - The branch of the phase starts at
-pi/2; its first positive Bessel zero corresponds to phase coordinate one. The Wronskian giveslambda'(k)=4a_k. Differentiating the inverse-phase ODE gives preciselylambda'''=(pi^6/2) H (H^2)'' > 0. - The trapezoidal expression for
2 C_iand midpoint expression forE_i-E_(i-1)have the asserted signs and constants. The initial interval is valid becauselambda'(0+)=0. - In the Green identity, the lower endpoint contributes
-1tor(phi F_s' - F_s phi'), so the integrated boundary difference is+1. This yields the coefficient1/(lambda_k+s^2)with the correct sign. - The difference series has coefficients
O(k^-3), hence uniform convergence on[0,1]from|J_0|<=1. The limit at zero islog(s/2)+gamma+K_0(s)/I_0(s). Differentiation yields the factor4sin the resolvent identity. - McMahon's expansion DLMF 10.21.19 and the Nicholson-integral amplitude expansion cancel the reciprocal term in
a_k, leaving an absolutely summableO(k^-3)correction. The denominator replacement contributesO((1+log s)/s^2)after the prescribed multiplication bys^4. - In the shifted Euler–Maclaurin calculation,
B_2(3/4)=-1/48, so the correction to the scaled sum is+1/(96A). Consequently the second resolvent coefficient is-1/16+pi^2/192and the renormalized sum is1/16-pi^2/192. The integrable fourth derivative gives the requiredO(A^-3)sum remainder. - The arithmetic limits are
C_i -> pi^2/12andE_i -> -pi^2/6. The identity expressingK_ias thea_j-weighted average ofC_(j-1)is exact and proves positivity, strict increase, and the limit. - The additional circle-constant consequence agrees with the measure identity and tends monotonically to
1/4; it does not establish the separate finite-degree circle conjecture.
Citation refinement
DLMF 10.23.18–20 supplies a direct Fourier–Bessel expansion theorem: weighted integrability and local bounded variation imply equality at each interior point. The smooth difference F_0-F_s satisfies these hypotheses. This provides a precise source for the interior equality before the uniformly convergent series is extended to zero. It can replace or supplement the draft's general reference to Hilbert-space completeness.