Audit date: 21 November 2026. Coordination: issue 180.
Verdict: the proposed proof of the intended monomial-product identity passes independent mathematical review. The argument covers every pair of partitions of the same size and all independent parameters in the defined multi- family. This audit does not establish priority, and it does not prove the separate Schur-positivity assertion.
1. Exact source and scope
The original source is Novelli and Thibon, arXiv:2502.09072v2, Conjecture 5.7, equations (87)–(88). I checked the definition of the modified family in Definition 5.3, equation (57), and the graph-descent expansion in Lemma 4.2, equation (35).
The conjecture concerns each Schur coefficient of . Its printed exponent must be read as , with the Schur index. The following example uses the coefficient of in and exponent , agreeing with rather than . The coefficient of likewise rules out a common exponent depending only on . The manuscript states and proves the intended indexed identity explicitly; it does not count the printing error as a disproof.
The informal suggestion about other normalized Yang–Baxter traces immediately preceding the conjecture is not included in the theorem proved here. Nor is Conjecture 5.4, which asserts nonnegative Schur coefficients.
2. Reading order, graph, arms, and legs
I checked these conventions independently in Haglund and Wilson, Macdonald polynomials and chromatic quasisymmetric functions, Electronic Journal of Combinatorics 27(3) (2020), P3.37, Definitions 1–3 and 14, printed pages 3–4 and 7.
The manuscript matches the source conventions: French diagrams; row reading from top to bottom and left to right; attacks within a row or between an upper-right cell and a lower-left cell in adjacent rows; arm to the right; leg above; augmented edges from each nonbottom cell to the cell directly below it.
Consequently every vertical comparison uses an earlier position followed by a later position. This matters because equal letters must be standardized in the same direction as the position order. The graph counts also follow:
The count of cells with , excluding the bottom row, is . In a column of height , the labels run once through .
3. Cancellation in the modified convention
The distinction between the source's untilded and modified functions is substantial. The proof correctly starts from equation (57), rather than transferring a formula for an untilded function without checking the parameter inversion.
For an optional vertical edge let be the corresponding descent indicator, let be the arm, and put . The included and excluded edge contributions sum to
This verifies the cancellation before setting . Multiplying these expressions and canceling the global prefactor leaves exactly
There is no remaining singularity in the derivative calculation. Even if one works in Laurent polynomials in before using nonnegativity of the HHL inversion statistic, expansion at remains valid.
4. The universal comparison identity
Let . The standardization identity
uses equal letters standardized from left to right. For , the comparison therefore holds exactly when . No equality case contributes. Summing over all words gives
The positions need not be adjacent. The other positions are unrestricted. Thus the identity applies to every attacking edge and to every vertical edge separately.
5. Derivatives and Schur extraction
Set . The first derivative in sums all attacking-edge indicators and subtracts the arm-weighted vertical indicators, giving
The derivative in gives
Both are exact identities of symmetric functions. The argument is coefficientwise in a finite alphabet and then stable in the alphabet size; it does not require an analytic convergence claim.
The coefficient of in is . Repeated one-cell Pieri additions start at the vertical shape and give exactly standard tableaux whose entries occupy that vertical pair. This verifies the tableau statistic and its shape index.
Finally, for a Schur coefficient , the derivatives at are the total exponents and . They are precisely the exponents in the conjectured monomial product. The resulting identity is
Integer signed multiplicities cause no problem in this formal Laurent monomial identity. No positivity assertion has been assumed. The size-one case is trivial, and the argument for every size at least two is uniform.
6. Audit limits
This review establishes the internal mathematics and the precise connection to the intended source statement. It does not assert that the result is new; that question requires the separate prior-resolution search. No finite experiment is used as evidence for the unbounded theorem, and no Lean work was performed.
7. Supplement: all hook Schur coefficients
The later hook-coefficient supplement was checked independently against the source's Theorem 3.2, equation (20), as well as Definition 5.3. It also passes.
To avoid a collision between the graph parameter and the plethystic variable, write the latter as . Theorem 3.2 and Carlsson–Mellit give, for a Dyck graph with incoming degrees ,
The incoming convention is explicit in Theorem 3.2: counts edges . Since , multiplying by the defining factor and applying yields
Every optional vertical edge enters a different lower cell, so the subset sum in Definition 5.3 factors cell by cell. For one such lower cell with base incoming degree , upper arm , and upper leg parameter , the local sum divided by is
If the lower cell is in column and has a cell above it in a row of length , then while . Thus . Without an upper cell its degree is already .
After cancellation of the global , a column of height contributes its labels in the order , where is the row counted from below. Reversing their order within this column preserves the product and the common factor. Consequently,
For degree , the only Schur functions surviving at are hooks, and
The cell supplies a factor on the product side. Dividing it out and comparing powers of gives the complete hook formula: the coefficient of equals the -th elementary symmetric function in the remaining cell monomials. The proof is uniform in the size and shape, and uses the modified convention throughout. It is a supplement to the same conjecture package, not an additional named-resolution count.