Roos–Seiringer’s conjecture

What Lean checks

Complete proposed computer-assisted proof of the full radial Dirichlet kernel assertion. Analytic tails and an essential exact certificate over 184 closed intervals cover the entire positive real axis; source scaling covers all positive chemical potentials. Two independent mathematical/code reviews, a separate priority audit and full replays passed. The unaveraged kernel is outside the claim. No Lean formalization is claimed.

Statement and scope

Barbara Roos and Robert Seiringer, BCS Critical Temperature on Half-Spaces, Archive for Rational Mechanics and Analysis 249 (2025), article 20, DOI 10.1007/s00205-025-02088-x, define a radial Dirichlet kernel in §5. Immediately after Lemma 5.1 and the figures they state that its nonnegativity appears true but is beyond their proof.

This is the complete scalar assertion stated there. The paper considers the physical dimensions one, two, and three, but does not propose a corresponding kernel-positivity conjecture over arbitrary dimensions. No partial dimensional case is substituted for a broader conjecture here.

For positive real xx, write

J(x)=∫1∞sin2(xk)karccothkdk,arccothk=12logk+1k−1.J(x)=\int_1^\infty \frac{\sin^2(xk)}{k}\mathop{\mathrm{arccoth}}k\,dk, \qquad \mathop{\mathrm{arccoth}}k=\frac12\log\frac{k+1}{k-1}.

The function from the source is

m(x)=4J(x)πx−2sin2xπx−2sin2xx2+4sinxπx2(sinxSi(2x)−cosxCin(2x)),m(x)=\frac{4J(x)}{\pi x} -\frac{2\sin^2x}{\pi x} -\frac{2\sin^2x}{x^2} +\frac{4\sin x}{\pi x^2} \left(\sin x\mathop{\mathrm{Si}}(2x) -\cos x\mathop{\mathrm{Cin}}(2x)\right),

where

Siy=∫0ysinttdt,Ciny=∫0y1−costtdt.\mathop{\mathrm{Si}}y=\int_0^y\frac{\sin t}{t}\,dt, \qquad \mathop{\mathrm{Cin}}y=\int_0^y\frac{1-\cos t}{t}\,dt.

Theorem. For every positive real xx, m(x)>0m(x)>0. Its continuous value at zero is zero.

The source's scaling identity (5.2) is

m3D(r;μ)=μ−1/2m(μr).m_3^D(r;\mu)=\mu^{-1/2}m(\sqrt\mu\,r).

Consequently the theorem gives m3D(r;μ)>0m_3^D(r;\mu)>0 for every r>0r>0 and μ>0\mu>0, with value zero at r=0r=0. This is the radial average defined in (5.1), and is not the unaveraged kernel denoted by a tilde in Remark 1.5.

The proof is computer assisted. Two analytic arguments treat the unbounded ends of the domain. An exact integer interval computation certifies all points in the remaining compact interval. The executable certificate is verify.py; it uses only the Python standard library. Its role is essential and is specified in §5.

Set

F(x)=πx24m(x)=xJ(x)−x+π2sin2x+sin2xSi(2x)−sinxcosxCin(2x).F(x)=\frac{\pi x^2}{4}m(x) =xJ(x)-\frac{x+\pi}{2}\sin^2x +\sin^2x\mathop{\mathrm{Si}}(2x) -\sin x\cos x\mathop{\mathrm{Cin}}(2x).

It suffices to prove F(x)>0F(x)>0.

1. An exact entire series

Put

Hk=∑j=1k1j,Ok=∑j=1k12j−1,Bk=1−(2k−1)Okk(2k+1)−2Hk2k+1.H_k=\sum_{j=1}^k\frac1j, \qquad O_k=\sum_{j=1}^k\frac1{2j-1}, \qquad B_k=1-\frac{(2k-1)O_k}{k(2k+1)}-\frac{2H_k}{2k+1}.

We claim the identity

F(x)=π4∑k=2∞(−1)k(2x)2k(2k)!k−12k−1+x4∑k=3∞(−1)k(2x)2k(2k)!Bk.F(x)=\frac\pi4\sum_{k=2}^\infty \frac{(-1)^k(2x)^{2k}}{(2k)!}\frac{k-1}{2k-1} +\frac x4\sum_{k=3}^\infty \frac{(-1)^k(2x)^{2k}}{(2k)!}B_k. \tag{1}

Both series converge locally uniformly in the complex plane. The identity is needed only for positive real xx.

Derivation

For x>0x>0, differentiation of the integral for JJ gives

J′(x)=∫1∞sin(2xk)arccothkdk.J'(x)=\int_1^\infty\sin(2xk)\mathop{\mathrm{arccoth}}k\,dk.

The logarithmic singularity at one is integrable. The tails of the derivative integral converge uniformly on compact positive xx-intervals by the Dirichlet test, since arccoth decreases to zero. The original integral converges uniformly there by absolute domination. These facts justify differentiation.

For y>0y>0, integration by parts, with the endpoint cancellation displayed, gives

∫1∞sin(yk)arccothkdk=1y∫1∞cosy−cos(yk)k2−1dk.\int_1^\infty\sin(yk)\mathop{\mathrm{arccoth}}k\,dk =\frac1y\int_1^\infty\frac{\cos y-\cos(yk)}{k^2-1}\,dk. \tag{2}

Indeed, cosy−cos(yk)\cos y-\cos(yk) vanishes at one; its product with arccoth also vanishes there. The boundary term at infinity vanishes because arccoth tends to zero.

Use 1/(k2−1)=12((k−1)−1−(k+1)−1)1/(k^2-1)=\tfrac12((k-1)^{-1}-(k+1)^{-1}) in (2). Shift the first resulting integral by k−1k-1 and the second by k+1k+1, first with finite cutoffs and then take their common limit. The segment from zero to two contributes

12∫02cosy(1−cos(yu))+sinysin(yu)udu.\frac12\int_0^2 \frac{\cos y(1-\cos(yu))+\sin y\sin(yu)}u\,du.

The remaining common tail contributes

siny∫2∞sin(yu)udu.\sin y\int_2^\infty\frac{\sin(yu)}u\,du.

The discrepancy of the shifted upper cutoffs tends to zero. Thus

J′(x)=cos(2x)Cin(4x)+sin(2x)(π−Si(4x))4x.J'(x)=\frac{ \cos(2x)\mathop{\mathrm{Cin}}(4x) +\sin(2x)(\pi-\mathop{\mathrm{Si}}(4x))}{4x}. \tag{3}

The combination in this formula also has the useful identity

cosyCin(2y)−sinySi(2y)=2∫01cosy−cos(yu)1−u2du.\cos y\mathop{\mathrm{Cin}}(2y)-\sin y\mathop{\mathrm{Si}}(2y) =2\int_0^1\frac{\cos y-\cos(yu)}{1-u^2}\,du. \tag{4}

To check (4), combine the defining integrals into ∫02[cosy−cos(y(1−v))]dv/v\int_0^2[\cos y-\cos(y(1-v))]\,dv/v, substitute u=1−vu=1-v, and pair uu and −u-u. In the power-series expansion,

∫011−u2k1−u2du=Ok.\int_0^1\frac{1-u^{2k}}{1-u^2}\,du=O_k.

Equations (3)–(4), followed by integration from zero, therefore imply

J(x)=π4Si(2x)+14∑k=1∞(−1)k(2x)2kk(2k)!Ok.J(x)=\frac\pi4\mathop{\mathrm{Si}}(2x) +\frac14\sum_{k=1}^\infty \frac{(-1)^k(2x)^{2k}}{k(2k)!}O_k. \tag{5}

Here J(0)=0J(0)=0 follows by dominated convergence: arccoth divided by kk is integrable on [1,∞)[1,\infty). The factorial denominators and Ok≤1+logkO_k\le 1+\log k justify the power-series integrations on compact sets.

For the other special-function combination, put y=2xy=2x. Trigonometric addition gives

sin2xSi(2x)−sinxcosxCin(2x)=12∫01sin(yt)−siny+sin(y(1−t))tdt=−12∑k=1∞(−1)ky2k+1(2k+1)!H2k.\begin{aligned} &\sin^2x\mathop{\mathrm{Si}}(2x) -\sin x\cos x\mathop{\mathrm{Cin}}(2x)\\ &\quad=\frac12\int_0^1 \frac{\sin(yt)-\sin y+\sin(y(1-t))}{t}\,dt\\ &\quad=-\frac12\sum_{k=1}^\infty \frac{(-1)^k y^{2k+1}}{(2k+1)!}H_{2k}. \end{aligned} \tag{6}

The last step uses

∫01t2k+1−1+(1−t)2k+1tdt=−H2k.\int_0^1\frac{t^{2k+1}-1+(1-t)^{2k+1}}t\,dt=-H_{2k}.

Substitute (5)–(6) into FF, expand the remaining sine square, and use H2k=Ok+Hk/2H_{2k}=O_k+H_k/2. The coefficient of the odd series is

1+Okk−4H2k2k+1=Bk,1+\frac{O_k}{k}-\frac{4H_{2k}}{2k+1}=B_k,

and the even series is the expansion of π4[xSi(2x)−(1−cos(2x))]\tfrac\pi4[x\mathop{\mathrm{Si}}(2x)-(1-\cos(2x))]. This proves (1), including the zero coefficients for k=1,2k=1,2 in its odd part.

2. Coefficient bounds and the interval from zero to one

Direct calculation gives

B1=B2=0,B3=19.B_1=B_2=0,\qquad B_3=\frac19.

The displayed definition shows Bk<1B_k<1. Moreover,

Bk+1−Bk=(4k2+4k)Hk+(4k2−3)Ok−6k2−3kk(k+1)(2k+1)(2k+3).B_{k+1}-B_k =\frac{(4k^2+4k)H_k+(4k^2-3)O_k-6k^2-3k} {k(k+1)(2k+1)(2k+3)}. \tag{7}

Since Hk,Ok≥1H_k,O_k\ge1, the numerator is at least 2k2+k−3=(k−1)(2k+3)2k^2+k-3=(k-1)(2k+3). Thus BkB_k is nondecreasing, and

19≤Bk<1(k≥3).\frac19\le B_k<1\qquad(k\ge3). \tag{8}

For 0<x≤10<x\le1, both series in (1) are alternating series with decreasing absolute terms. For the even series the ratio of successive absolute terms is at most 8/30<18/30<1; for the odd series (8) bounds it by 36/56<136/56<1.

Keep the first two terms of the even series and the first term of the odd series. Their alternating remainders have the required sign, giving

F(x)≥π(x418−2x6225)−x7405≥(7π150−1405)x4>5574050x4>0.\begin{aligned} F(x)&\ge\pi\left(\frac{x^4}{18}-\frac{2x^6}{225}\right)-\frac{x^7}{405}\\ &\ge\left(\frac{7\pi}{150}-\frac1{405}\right)x^4 >\frac{557}{4050}x^4>0. \end{aligned} \tag{9}

Only π>3\pi>3 is used in the final strict inequality. Formula (1) also gives m(x)=2x2/9+O(x4)m(x)=2x^2/9+O(x^4), so the continuous extension has m(0)=0m(0)=0.

3. The entire interval from forty to infinity

For k>1k>1 the positive series

arccothkk=∑j=0∞1(2j+1)k2j+2\frac{\mathop{\mathrm{arccoth}}k}{k} =\sum_{j=0}^\infty\frac1{(2j+1)k^{2j+2}}

can be truncated from below. Define

q(k)=∑j=071(2j+1)k2j+2,H=∑j=0712j+1,S=∑j=071(2j+1)2.q(k)=\sum_{j=0}^7\frac1{(2j+1)k^{2j+2}}, \quad H=\sum_{j=0}^7\frac1{2j+1}, \quad S=\sum_{j=0}^7\frac1{(2j+1)^2}.

The positive function qq decreases from HH to zero. Integration by parts gives

|∫1∞q(k)cos(2xk)dk|≤q(1)+∫1∞|q′(k)|dk2x=Hx.\left|\int_1^\infty q(k)\cos(2xk)\,dk\right| \le\frac{q(1)+\int_1^\infty|q'(k)|\,dk}{2x} =\frac Hx.

Consequently

J(x)≥S2−H2x.J(x)\ge\frac S2-\frac H{2x}. \tag{10}

Write R(x)=π/2−Si(2x)R(x)=\pi/2-\mathop{\mathrm{Si}}(2x). The defining expression for FF becomes

F(x)=xJ(x)−x2sin2x−R(x)sin2x−sinxcosxCin(2x).F(x)=xJ(x)-\frac x2\sin^2x-R(x)\sin^2x -\sin x\cos x\mathop{\mathrm{Cin}}(2x). \tag{11}

Elementary integration by parts in the sine and cosine tails yields

|R(x)|≤1x,|Ci(y)|≤2y(y>0).|R(x)|\le\frac1x, \qquad |\mathop{\mathrm{Ci}}(y)|\le\frac2y\quad(y>0).

Using Ciny=γ+logy−Ciy\mathop{\mathrm{Cin}}y=\gamma+\log y-\mathop{\mathrm{Ci}}y and γ<1\gamma<1, we obtain

0≤Cin(2x)≤1+log(2x)+1x.0\le\mathop{\mathrm{Cin}}(2x)\le1+\log(2x)+\frac1x.

Combining these estimates with (10)–(11) gives

F(x)≥cx−H2−1+log(2x)2−32x=:G(x),c=S−12=82172963811620810.F(x)\ge c x-\frac H2-\frac{1+\log(2x)}2-\frac3{2x} =:G(x), \qquad c=\frac{S-1}{2}=\frac{82172963}{811620810}. \tag{12}

For x≥40x\ge40,

G′(x)=c−12x+32x2>c−180>0.G'(x)=c-\frac1{2x}+\frac3{2x^2}>c-\frac1{80}>0.

The elementary inequality log80<9/2\log80<9/2 gives

G(40)>40c−H2−114−380=16324629136492966480>0.G(40)>40c-\frac H2-\frac{11}4-\frac3{80} =\frac{1632462913}{6492966480}>0. \tag{13}

The verifier checks every rational comparison in this paragraph. It proves the logarithmic bound by summing sixteen positive terms of the exponential series for e9/2e^{9/2} and checking that their sum exceeds eighty. Hence (12)–(13) prove positivity for every x≥40x\ge40.

4. A derivative bound on the compact interval

We will use the following deliberately coarse bound. If 1≤a≤x≤b≤401\le a\le x\le b\le40, then

|F′(x)|≤14+b2.|F'(x)|\le14+\frac b2. \tag{14}

First, 0≤J(x)<20\le J(x)<2. In fact, termwise integration of the positive arccoth series gives

J(x)≤∑j=0∞1(2j+1)2≤32<2,J(x)\le\sum_{j=0}^\infty\frac1{(2j+1)^2}\le\frac32<2,

where the tail after j=0j=0 is bounded by the integral of the decreasing function 1/(2t+1)21/(2t+1)^2 over [0,∞)[0,\infty).

The bounds from §3, π<4\pi<4, log80<9/2\log80<9/2, and log160<6\log160<6 give throughout [1,40][1,40]

Cin(2x)≤132,Cin(4x)≤152,|Si(4x)|≤52,|R(x)|≤1.\mathop{\mathrm{Cin}}(2x)\le\frac{13}2, \quad\mathop{\mathrm{Cin}}(4x)\le\frac{15}2, \quad|\mathop{\mathrm{Si}}(4x)|\le\frac52, \quad|R(x)|\le1.

Equation (3) therefore implies |xJ′(x)|≤7/2|xJ'(x)|\le7/2. Differentiate the definition of FF; the derivatives of the Si and Cin factors cancel in pairs. The result is

F′(x)=J(x)+xJ′(x)−12sin2x−x2sin(2x)−R(x)sin(2x)−Cin(2x)cos(2x).F'(x)=J(x)+xJ'(x)-\frac12\sin^2x -\frac x2\sin(2x)-R(x)\sin(2x) -\mathop{\mathrm{Cin}}(2x)\cos(2x).

Its absolute value is at most 2+7/2+1/2+b/2+1+13/2=27/2+b/2<14+b/22+7/2+1/2+b/2+1+13/2=27/2+b/2<14+b/2, proving (14). The verifier checks e6>160e^6>160 using a positive finite exponential sum.

5. Exact certificate covering every point of the compact interval

All numerical quantities in this section are rational enclosures, computed with integers. There are no floating-point evaluations of the kernel, special functions, or transcendental constants.

Truncation error

Truncate both series in (1) after k=160k=160. The coefficient bounds in §2, π<4\pi<4, and x≤40x\le40 show that the absolute remainder is less than

2280322322!<2−128.22\frac{80^{322}}{322!}<2^{-128}. \tag{15}

For the first inequality, the first omitted term is 80322/322!80^{322}/322! and every subsequent absolute-term ratio is less than one half. Multiplication by the combined prefactor (π+x)/4<11(\pi+x)/4<11 gives twenty-two times that term. The second inequality is an exact integer comparison in the verifier.

Rational interval evaluation

An interval is represented by an integer pair (l,u)(l,u) and denotes [l/2384,u/2384][l/2^{384},u/2^{384}]. Every arithmetic operation rounds its lower endpoint down and its upper endpoint up by integer division. The partial-series terms are generated recursively from

T0=1,Tk=Tk−14x2(2k−1)(2k).T_0=1,\qquad T_k=T_{k-1}\frac{4x^2}{(2k-1)(2k)}.

The coefficients in (1) are exact rational numbers. Alternating terms are added or subtracted by interval arithmetic. Pi is enclosed by Machin’s identity

π=16arctan(1/5)−4arctan(1/239),\pi=16\arctan(1/5)-4\arctan(1/239),

using respectively 128 and 40 terms of their alternating series, with the first omitted term bounding each remainder. Finally the interval is enlarged at each endpoint by 2−1282^{-128} as required by (15).

Coverage and the analytic consumer

Start with the closed interval [1,40][1,40]. For any current closed interval [a,b][a,b], evaluate the enclosed value of FF at its rational midpoint z=(a+b)/2z=(a+b)/2. Let LL be its rational lower endpoint. Certify the entire interval when

L−(14+b2)b−a2>0.L-\left(14+\frac b2\right)\frac{b-a}2>0. \tag{16}

By (14) and the fundamental theorem of calculus, (16) implies F(x)>0F(x)>0 for every point of [a,b][a,b]. If (16) is not certified, replace the parent by both closed halves and repeat. Each replacement preserves the union, including shared endpoints.

The provided verifier terminates with 184 successful leaf intervals, after 367 evaluations. It independently sorts the leaves and verifies that adjacent endpoints agree and that their total length is exactly 39. The deepest leaf has subdivision depth 11. The smallest certified margin in (16) is the positive rational number

36518669520975538443399909769384499217477851925675650280413387079105869496664773000114949154882589870915233607065539402006196394479212279040100143613805079739270465446667948293404245721771497210611414266254884915640806627990306816.\frac{ 365186695209755384433999097693844992174778519256756502804133870791058694966647730001149491548825898709152336070655 }{ 39402006196394479212279040100143613805079739270465446667948293404245721771497210611414266254884915640806627990306816 }.

The SHA256 of the sorted exact leaf records is 7bf6b5aa90b010e4f66872bdbb4c4110ada7a0e2f55528f86dcfa86c5a107166.

These finite exact comparisons establish (16) on a complete cover. They prove the continuous statement on [1,40][1,40]; they are not merely sign tests at selected points.

6. Conclusion

Equation (9) treats every x∈(0,1]x\in(0,1], the certificate treats every x∈[1,40]x\in[1,40], and (12)–(13) treat every x∈[40,∞)x\in[40,\infty). Thus F(x)>0F(x)>0 for every positive real xx, and the defining positive factor gives m(x)>0m(x)>0 there. The expansion at zero already gives m(0)=0m(0)=0.

This resolves the whole kernel-nonnegativity assertion from §5 of the source. It does not separately claim or count a result about another dimension, the unaveraged kernel, or Neumann boundary conditions.