Catalogue · Disproof · Sources · Independent audit
Result
The unweighted generalized Jacobi–Stirling row polynomials do not form a coefficientwise Hankel-totally-positive sequence. With the source parameters renamed, put
where entries outside the triangle are zero. The exact determinant identity is
The coefficient of the monomial a squared times x to the fourth power is minus four. This disproves the complete universal conjecture. The same formula gives a negative determinant for every positive a, nonnegative b and x greater than the product (a+b)(2a+b)(3a+b) divided by twice a squared. In particular, the strictly positive choice (a,b,x)=(1,1,13) gives −8788.
The conjecture is the unweighted assertion in §5.2 of Zhu's paper, immediately after equation (5.10). Proposition 5.7 concerns the different factorial-weighted sequence.
Review and priority
A separate internal audit checked the source normalization, derived the polynomial identity independently, and verified the strict interior counterexample. The source audit records primary and adjacent papers, both search engines, and public solution archives. No earlier disproof was located within the stated search scope. The notes remain unrefereed, with the source-access and indexing limits recorded explicitly.
Lean status: The Lean proof formalizes the recurrence, the actual matrix determinant and polynomial identity, the coefficient −4, the full quantified conjecture and its negation, and the stated negative region over linearly ordered fields. Its standalone strict source check, all-owned axiom audit and stock-kernel replay passed. The combined repository gate for this registration is pending.
Reproduce
From the repository root:
python3 results/zhu-jacobi-stirling/verify.pyThe standard-library script constructs sparse integer polynomials directly from the triangle recurrence and expands the determinant over its six permutations. It verifies the entire identity over the integer polynomial ring; the short hand proof is in PROOF.md.
Source
Bao-Xuan Zhu, Coefficientwise Hankel-total positivity of the row-generating polynomials for the output matrices of certain production matrices, Advances in Mathematics 444 (2024), 109695, doi:10.1016/j.aim.2024.109695, author manuscript, §5.2, printed page 24.
Research and review: issue 163.