López Pouso–Segura's node conjecture

What Lean checks

Lean checks the two Legendre roots, standard weight formula, exact cubic quadrature, and the two failed inequalities; the degree-two polynomial and its derivative are connected to mathlib’s shifted Legendre polynomial. Strict source compilation, one-module kernel replay and endpoint axiom checks passed. Lean also verifies the explicit perturbation functions, derivatives, differential equations final coefficient algebra, and the deduction of the scaled limit and eventual violation from three separate factor approximations with vanishing second-order remainders. Controlled ODE and root asymptotics, the gamma-ratio expansion, those factor approximations and the full repository gate remain pending.

The strict upper inequalities in published Conjectures 3 and 7 are false. One exact two-point Gauss–Legendre rule disproves both. For Conjecture 3, a controlled asymptotic expansion also proves failure at the smallest positive node for every sufficiently large even degree.

With κ=n+1/2\kappa=n+1/2, primary node xix_i and the source's secondary node ziz_i, the conjectured bound is

xizi−1<π212κ2.\frac{x_i}{z_i}-1<\frac{\pi^2}{12\kappa^2}.

For n=2n=2 the relevant ratio equals 2/3−1>1/7>π2/752/\sqrt3-1>1/7>\pi^2/75. For n=2m→∞n=2m\to\infty, the stronger obstruction is

xm+1zm+1=1+π212κ2+π4120κ4+O(κ−6).\frac{x_{m+1}}{z_{m+1}} =1+\frac{\pi^2}{12\kappa^2} +\frac{\pi^4}{120\kappa^4}+O(\kappa^{-6}).

The positive fourth-order term rules out an eventual version of the exact upper bound. The leading asymptotic constant is unchanged.

Source: Óscar López Pouso and Javier Segura, Uniform relations between the Gauss–Legendre nodes and weights, Journal of Inequalities and Applications (2025), article 40, published full text, Sections 4.1 and 4.3.

The Legendre equation, weight formula, gamma-ratio asymptotics and prior general node/weight expansions are credited as existing mathematics. The contribution is their explicit contradiction to the published strict upper bounds. The two related assertions count as one package. The separate Bessel-limit package concerns different limits and is compatible with this disproof.

Status: complete proposed disproof, independently reviewed internally; unrefereed. No earlier explicit refutation was found in the documented search. A related inaccessible full text remains an explicit priority-audit limit.

Lean status: partial.

The exact two-node disproof is checked in Conjectures.LopezPousoSegura, including the roots, weights, cubic quadrature and both inequalities. Strict compilation and isolated kernel replay passed; the eventual-even-degree strengthening and combined repository gate remain pending.