The strict upper inequalities in published Conjectures 3 and 7 are false. One exact two-point Gauss–Legendre rule disproves both. For Conjecture 3, a controlled asymptotic expansion also proves failure at the smallest positive node for every sufficiently large even degree.
With , primary node and the source's secondary node , the conjectured bound is
For the relevant ratio equals . For , the stronger obstruction is
The positive fourth-order term rules out an eventual version of the exact upper bound. The leading asymptotic constant is unchanged.
Source: Óscar López Pouso and Javier Segura, Uniform relations between the Gauss–Legendre nodes and weights, Journal of Inequalities and Applications (2025), article 40, published full text, Sections 4.1 and 4.3.
- Complete disproof
- Independent mathematical audit
- Source and prior-resolution audit
- Research discussion, issue 184
The Legendre equation, weight formula, gamma-ratio asymptotics and prior general node/weight expansions are credited as existing mathematics. The contribution is their explicit contradiction to the published strict upper bounds. The two related assertions count as one package. The separate Bessel-limit package concerns different limits and is compatible with this disproof.
Status: complete proposed disproof, independently reviewed internally; unrefereed. No earlier explicit refutation was found in the documented search. A related inaccessible full text remains an explicit priority-audit limit.
Lean status: partial.
The exact two-node disproof is checked in Conjectures.LopezPousoSegura, including the roots, weights, cubic quadrature and both inequalities. Strict compilation and isolated kernel replay passed; the eventual-even-degree strengthening and combined repository gate remain pending.