Independent audit of López Pouso–Segura's quadrature conjectures

What Lean checks

Lean checks the two Legendre roots, standard weight formula, exact cubic quadrature, and the two failed inequalities; the degree-two polynomial and its derivative are connected to mathlib’s shifted Legendre polynomial. Strict source compilation, one-module kernel replay and endpoint axiom checks passed. Lean also verifies the explicit perturbation functions, derivatives, differential equations final coefficient algebra, and the deduction of the scaled limit and eventual violation from three separate factor approximations with vanishing second-order remainders. Controlled ODE and root asymptotics, the gamma-ratio expansion, those factor approximations and the full repository gate remain pending.

Reviewed on 21 November 2026. This audit reconstructs the calculation from the Legendre differential equation. It does not infer an infinite statement from sampled quadrature rules.

Verdict and scope

The proposed disproof of Conjecture 3 passes. For every sufficiently large even degree, the smallest positive primary node violates the asserted upper bound. The fourth-order coefficient is strictly positive. Thus restricting the inequality to sufficiently large degrees would not repair it.

The exact two-point rule also disproves Conjecture 7 as written. The calculation below establishes eventual failure only for Conjecture 3; it makes no corresponding eventual claim for Conjecture 7.

This is a mathematical audit. Historical priority requires the separate literature audit.

Exact source conventions

The primary source is Óscar López Pouso and Javier Segura, Uniform relations between the Gauss–Legendre nodes and weights, Journal of Inequalities and Applications 2025, article 40, published 20 March 2025.

Section 4, equations (13) and (14), defines the cumulative nodes and their midpoints by

z‾i=−1+∑j=1iwj,zi=z‾i−1+z‾i2.\bar z_i=-1+\sum_{j=1}^{i}w_j, \qquad z_i=\frac{\bar z_{i-1}+\bar z_i}{2}.

Conjecture 3 asserts, at all defined ratios,

0<xizi−1<π212κ2,κ=n+12.0<\frac{x_i}{z_i}-1<\frac{\pi^2}{12\kappa^2}, \qquad \kappa=n+\frac12.

For even n=2mn=2m, symmetry gives z‾m=0\bar z_m=0 and zm+1=wm+1/2z_{m+1}=w_{m+1}/2, as the source's Remark 1 states. The conjectured inequality itself has no eventual-degree restriction. Remark 2 explicitly excludes ratios of the form 0/00/0, so such ratios are not counterexamples.

Conjecture 7 uses αi=−2∑j=1ixjwj\alpha_i=-2\sum_{j=1}^i x_jw_j and asserts the same upper bound for αi/(1−z‾i2)−1\alpha_i/(1-\bar z_i^2)-1.

Exact low-degree obstruction

For n=2n=2, the nodes are ±1/3\pm1/\sqrt3 and both weights are 11. Consequently z2=1/2z_2=1/2, z‾1=0\bar z_1=0, and α1=2/3\alpha_1=2/\sqrt3. Both conjectured error ratios equal

23−1>17>π275.\frac2{\sqrt3}-1>\frac17>\frac{\pi^2}{75}.

The first comparison follows from 3<7/4\sqrt3<7/4. For the second, π<22/7\pi<22/7 gives π2/75<484/3675<1/7\pi^2/75<484/3675<1/7, with the last integer comparison 3388<36753388<3675. Since 12κ2=7512\kappa^2=75, both asserted upper bounds fail exactly.

Independent reconstruction of the central asymptotics

Put ϵ=κ−2\epsilon=\kappa^{-2} and normalize the even Legendre polynomial by

f(u;ϵ)=cos(u/κ)Pn(sin(u/κ))Pn(0).f(u;\epsilon)= \frac{\sqrt{\cos(u/\kappa)}\,P_n(\sin(u/\kappa))}{P_n(0)}.

Substitution into (1−x2)Pn″−2xPn′+n(n+1)Pn=0(1-x^2)P_n''-2xP_n'+n(n+1)P_n=0 gives the exact equation

f″+(1+ϵ4sec2(ϵu))f=0,f(0)=1,f′(0)=0.f''+\left(1+\frac\epsilon4\sec^2(\sqrt\epsilon\,u)\right)f=0, \qquad f(0)=1,\quad f'(0)=0.

The coefficient is analytic in ϵ\epsilon near zero on a fixed compact interval containing u0=π/2u_0=\pi/2. Analytic dependence of the initial-value problem, together with the simple zero of cosu\cos u at u0u_0, justifies expansion of the solution, its derivative, and its nearby zero, with uniform remainders. Uniform convergence to cosu\cos u on the interval before that zero ensures this is the smallest positive zero when ϵ\epsilon is small.

Writing f=f0+ϵf1+ϵ2f2+O(ϵ3)f=f_0+\epsilon f_1+\epsilon^2 f_2+O(\epsilon^3), the coefficient equations and the initial conditions give

f0(u)=cosu,f1(u)=−usinu8,f2(u)=9128(usinu−u2cosu)−u3sinu24.\begin{aligned} f_0(u)&=\cos u,\\ f_1(u)&=-\frac{u\sin u}{8},\\ f_2(u)&=\frac9{128}(u\sin u-u^2\cos u) -\frac{u^3\sin u}{24}. \end{aligned}

In particular f1″+f1=−cosu/4f_1''+f_1=-\cos u/4 and f2″+f2=usinu/32−u2cosu/4f_2''+f_2=u\sin u/32-u^2\cos u/4, which directly verifies both correction terms.

Let uϵu_\epsilon be the first positive zero. Expanding the equation f(uϵ;ϵ)=0f(u_\epsilon;\epsilon)=0 gives

uϵ=u0−u08ϵ+(11u0128−u0324)ϵ2+O(ϵ3),u_\epsilon=u_0-\frac{u_0}{8}\epsilon +\left(\frac{11u_0}{128}-\frac{u_0^3}{24}\right)\epsilon^2 +O(\epsilon^3),

and differentiating the displayed solution gives

f′(uϵ;ϵ)2=1+ϵ4+u02−18ϵ2+O(ϵ3).f'(u_\epsilon;\epsilon)^2 =1+\frac\epsilon4+\frac{u_0^2-1}{8}\epsilon^2+O(\epsilon^3).

The exact central value P2m(0)=(−1)m(2mm)/4mP_{2m}(0)=(-1)^m\binom{2m}{m}/4^m and Stirling's expansion, with κ=2m+1/2\kappa=2m+1/2, give

P2m(0)2=2πκ(1−18κ2+11128κ4+O(κ−6)).P_{2m}(0)^2= \frac2{\pi\kappa} \left(1-\frac1{8\kappa^2} +\frac{11}{128\kappa^4}+O(\kappa^{-6})\right).

These coefficients were also reconstructed by squaring the central-binomial expansion in m−1m^{-1} and substituting m=(κ−1/2)/2m=(\kappa-1/2)/2.

At the corresponding node x=sin(uϵ/κ)x=\sin(u_\epsilon/\kappa), the derivative transformation and the exact Gaussian weight formula yield

w=2cos(uϵ/κ)κ2Pn(0)2f′(uϵ;ϵ)2,2xw=κ2Pn(0)2tan(uϵ/κ)f′(uϵ;ϵ)2.w=\frac{2\cos(u_\epsilon/\kappa)} {\kappa^2P_n(0)^2 f'(u_\epsilon;\epsilon)^2}, \qquad \frac{2x}{w}= \kappa^2P_n(0)^2 \tan(u_\epsilon/\kappa) f'(u_\epsilon;\epsilon)^2.

Multiplying the expansions, all nongeometric terms cancel through order ϵ2\epsilon^2:

2xw=1+u023ϵ+2u0415ϵ2+O(ϵ3)=1+π212κ2+π4120κ4+O(κ−6).\frac{2x}{w} =1+\frac{u_0^2}{3}\epsilon+\frac{2u_0^4}{15}\epsilon^2 +O(\epsilon^3) =1+\frac{\pi^2}{12\kappa^2} +\frac{\pi^4}{120\kappa^4}+O(\kappa^{-6}).

The positive coefficient π4/120\pi^4/120 therefore makes the conjectured strict upper bound fail for every sufficiently large even degree. The leading coefficient π2/12\pi^2/12 remains correct, so this disproof does not contradict the source's leading-order asymptotic relation.

Checks and limitations

The transformation, coefficient equations, root expansion, derivative square, amplitude conversion, and final multiplication were independently derived. Local symbolic algebra checked the polynomial identities; it was not used to estimate an infinite tail. The analytic remainder follows from the differential equation and the implicit-function theorem. No Lean work was performed.

The separately proposed Bessel-sequence results and the classical interlacing assertion are outside this audit. They cannot be inferred to fail from this counterexample.