The full asymptotic-normality statement in Sagan and Swanson, q-Stirling numbers in type B, Conjecture 7.8 is proved here. For every sequence of integers with and , the coefficient distributions of all four polynomials
converge to the standard normal law after centering by their actual means and dividing by their actual standard deviations.
The complete proof uses the elementary and complete homogeneous symmetric-function expressions. Each coefficient distribution is represented exactly as a sum of independent uniform marks attached to Bernoulli or geometric counts, conditioned on the total count. A direct Fourier argument controls this conditioning event and proves the normal limit. Exponential tilting proves convergence of the actual moments. The limiting variance is strictly positive and has order .
This is a complete unrefereed result. Independent analytic, source/model, and root mathematical audits passed. The literature and scope record describes the searches and distinguishes earlier results. No earlier resolution of the exact full conjecture was found; the search does not establish exclusive priority.
Files and verification
- PROOF.md: self-contained conditional-limit proof and all four parameter specializations.
- NOVELTY.md: primary sources, later papers, older probability literature, search record, and audit status.
- verify_model.py: exact rational checks of the conditional models against the defining recurrences.
Run:
python3 results/sagan-swanson-normality/verify_model.pyThe checker passes 168 exact identities across all four families and two auxiliary parameter choices. These finite checks verify algebraic models and indexing; the asymptotic conclusion is proved analytically.
Scope and source
The target is the full proportional regime for all four families. The separate coefficient log-concavity, parity log-concavity, bottom-heaviness, and boundary-regime questions are not claimed solved here.
- Published primary paper, European Journal of Combinatorics 118 (2024), 103899; Conjecture 7.8 on printed page 32.
- DOI
- arXiv:2205.14078
- Research and review issue 92