Sagan–Swanson conjecture

What Lean checks

Written proof of all four stated asymptotic normality assertions using actual means and variances; finite model checks are supplementary.

The full asymptotic-normality statement in Sagan and Swanson, q-Stirling numbers in type B, Conjecture 7.8 is proved here. For every sequence of integers with n,k→∞n,k\to\infty and k/n→α∈(0,1)k/n\to\alpha\in(0,1), the coefficient distributions of all four polynomials

S[n,k],c[n,k],SB[n,k],cB[n,k]S[n,k],\qquad c[n,k],\qquad S_B[n,k],\qquad c_B[n,k]

converge to the standard normal law after centering by their actual means and dividing by their actual standard deviations.

The complete proof uses the elementary and complete homogeneous symmetric-function expressions. Each coefficient distribution is represented exactly as a sum of independent uniform marks attached to Bernoulli or geometric counts, conditioned on the total count. A direct Fourier argument controls this conditioning event and proves the normal limit. Exponential tilting proves convergence of the actual moments. The limiting variance is strictly positive and has order n3n^3.

This is a complete unrefereed result. Independent analytic, source/model, and root mathematical audits passed. The literature and scope record describes the searches and distinguishes earlier results. No earlier resolution of the exact full conjecture was found; the search does not establish exclusive priority.

Files and verification

  • PROOF.md: self-contained conditional-limit proof and all four parameter specializations.
  • NOVELTY.md: primary sources, later papers, older probability literature, search record, and audit status.
  • verify_model.py: exact rational checks of the conditional models against the defining recurrences.

Run:

python3 results/sagan-swanson-normality/verify_model.py

The checker passes 168 exact identities across all four families and two auxiliary parameter choices. These finite checks verify algebraic models and indexing; the asymptotic conclusion is proved analytically.

Scope and source

The target is the full proportional regime for all four families. The separate coefficient log-concavity, parity log-concavity, bottom-heaviness, and boundary-regime questions are not claimed solved here.