Literature and scope record

What Lean checks

Written proof of all four stated asymptotic normality assertions using actual means and variances; finite model checks are supplementary.

Checked on 20 November 2026. No earlier resolution of the full four-family proportional-regime statement was located in the sources below. This is a bounded literature screen; it does not establish exclusive priority.

Exact target

  • Bruce E. Sagan and Joshua P. Swanson, q-Stirling numbers in type B, European Journal of Combinatorics 118 (2024), 103899, DOI 10.1016/j.ejc.2023.103899. Published full text, NSF copy, arXiv:2205.14078.
  • The exact conjecture is 7.8, printed page 32. The coefficient distributions of the four fixed-(n,k)(n,k) polynomials are the objects being standardized. Theorem 7.7 immediately before it treats fixed kk for the second-kind families, a different regime. The paper's ordinary Stirling row-normality references also concern a different distribution.
  • The type-B symmetric-function formulas occur in Theorem 2.1. The four defining recurrences and their indexing were checked directly by two agents against the published text.

Subsequent work inspected

  1. Sagan and Swanson, Stirling numbers for complex reflection groups, author manuscript, arXiv:2408.13874, published record. This followup extends the algebraic and combinatorial constructions. The complete 26-page author manuscript was searched for asymptotic results; it does not contain a normal-limit theorem resolving Conjecture 7.8.

  2. Swanson's current publication and project page, including its 2026 entries. No subsequent resolution of this conjecture was listed there when checked.

  3. Shi-Mei Ma, Log-concavity and log-convexity of Stirling columns, and bottom-heaviness of q-Stirling numbers, September 2026. ChinaRxiv record, author-uploaded full text. Its second result settles Sagan–Swanson Conjecture 7.6 on bottom-heaviness. The full text contains no claim resolving asymptotic normality. Its other result concerns the log-concavity-to-log-convexity transition in columns of ordinary Stirling numbers.

  4. Trure Turing's bottom-heaviness release. This public result record explicitly distinguishes its bottom-heaviness theorem from asymptotic normality, which it lists among the remaining questions. It was used as a current status cross-check, not as a mathematical premise. Its reported independent bottom-heaviness settlement is also a different conjecture.

Older probability literature and scope checks

  • Svante Janson, Moment convergence in conditional limit theorems, Journal of Applied Probability 38 (2001), 421–437. Publisher record and abstract, author PDF. The abstract describes conditional sums and moment convergence for independent identically distributed pairs. Conditional-limit methods are established tools; the present proof does not claim to invent them. Our pairs depend on the index and form a triangular array, and the needed estimates are proved directly. Full-text retrieval of this older paper failed during this screen, so no claim is made to have audited every theorem in it.

  • Davide Crippa, Klaus Simon and Paul Trunz, Markov Processes Involving q-Stirling Numbers, Combinatorics, Probability and Computing 6 (1997), 165–178. Publisher record, ETH report manuscript. The full report was accessed. Its process uses qq as a numerical transition-probability parameter; its distribution varies the state index. This does not identify the fixed-(n,k)(n,k) coefficient distribution required here. The scanned extraction is imperfect, and the scope distinction was checked in its introduction rather than inferred from the title alone.

  • Searches also returned normality for ordinary Stirling rows, record statistics with numerical qq, descents on Stirling permutations, and cyclotomic generating functions. These statements concern different distributions. A general central limit theorem by itself does not discharge the conditioning, indexing, variance, and moment checks in the proof.

Search record

Both available search engines were used, including current-year and exact-statement searches. Independent agents repeated the target-specific screen. Queries included:

  • "Sagan" "Swanson" "asymptotically normal"
  • "Conjecture 7.8" "Stirling"
  • "Sagan" "Swanson" "7.8" proof
  • "Sagan–Swanson" "normality"
  • "q-Stirling" "asymptotic normality" 2025 2026
  • "q-Stirling" "coefficients" "central limit theorem"
  • "q-Stirling" "coefficient distributions" normal
  • "Stirling" "k/n" "normal" q coefficients
  • "Stirling" "conditional central limit" q
  • "Carlitz" "Stirling" "central limit" inversion fixed blocks
  • "inversions" "set partitions" "asymptotic normality"
  • "set partitions" "k blocks" "inversions" normal distribution
  • "Stirling numbers for complex reflection groups" asymptotic
  • "Sagan" "Swanson" "normality" proof counterexample
  • "2205.14078" "normal" proof conjecture

No exact prior proof or disproof appeared in these searches. The proof is an unrefereed result and remains subject to correction if an earlier resolution or a mathematical error is identified.

Independent audit record

The analysis reviewer checked the whole argument, with particular attention to the geometric characteristic-function denominator, a uniform gap below the geometric singularity, the full Fourier-domain bound, conditioning probability, exponential tilting, and actual-moment standardization. The combinatorics reviewer checked the exact published statement, all four symmetric-function identities, count/mark generating functions, and the parameter table. Both audits passed. The root reviewer then independently checked the complete corrected proof, including all analytic steps, and also found no gap. The combinatorics audit records its source and model checks. These are internal reviews, not external peer review.

A formatting edit briefly duplicated Section 1 in the initial research commit. Commit 9e532ccded16775b44f6f5f489e259c36a46f3b2 removed those repetitions; the analytic argument was unchanged.